The Test-Optional Era Is Ending at Many Schools

The pandemic-era test-optional policies that swept through higher education between 2020 and 2023 are being reversed at a growing number of institutions. Several schools that suspended testing requirements during COVID have reinstated them, and the trend is accelerating as colleges have now had several cycles to analyze how test-optional admissions affected their incoming class data.

The schools that went test-required again read like a short list of highly selective universities: Harvard, Dartmouth, Brown, Yale, MIT, and Georgetown reinstated requirements. The University of Florida reinstated them for in-state applicants. Several other schools are in transition, having signaled intentions to return to test requirements without yet formally implementing them.

Before making any decision about whether to take or submit a standardized test, confirm the current policy for every school on your list directly from their official admissions site. The landscape is changing quickly, and an article from two cycles ago is not a reliable guide.

Schools With Confirmed Testing Requirements in 2026–2027

These schools require SAT or ACT scores for the 2026–2027 application cycle:

Harvard University, Yale University, Dartmouth College, Brown University, MIT, Georgetown University (new to Common App this cycle), University of Florida, University of Georgia, Georgia Tech, University of North Carolina Chapel Hill.

Note: Policies at Columbia, Cornell, University of Pennsylvania, Princeton, and Stanford remained in transition as of the time of writing. Some have signaled returns to testing requirements for certain classes — verify directly.

Test-Optional Schools Where Scores Still Matter

Being test-optional does not mean scores are ignored when submitted. The evidence from multiple admissions cycles is consistent: at test-optional selective schools, students who submit strong test scores are admitted at meaningfully higher rates than those who do not submit scores, even when controlling for GPA and other factors.

Test-optional means you are not required to submit scores. It does not mean scores are neutral if submitted. If your score is strong, submitting it generally helps. If your score is weak relative to the school's admitted range, withholding it is often the correct strategy.

How to assess "strong" vs "weak": look at each school's 25th and 75th percentile SAT and ACT scores for their enrolled class. This data is in the school's Common Data Set, available on their website or through the College Board's search tool. If your score is above the 50th percentile — that is, above the midpoint between 25th and 75th percentile — submitting it almost certainly helps. Below the 25th percentile, withholding is generally the right call. In between, the decision is nuanced and depends on how you are otherwise framing your application.

The "Holistic" Review at Test-Optional Schools

When a school receives an application without test scores, admissions officers typically weight other parts of the application more heavily — GPA, course rigor, recommendations, and essays — to compensate for the missing data point. This does not mean test-optional applicants are disadvantaged. It means the rest of the application needs to be correspondingly stronger.

The schools that have fully committed to test-optional review have generally updated their admissions training accordingly. The practical effect: if you are a strong student with a less-than-ideal test score, test-optional admission is genuinely accessible at many schools. But "test-optional" is not a backdoor to schools where you are otherwise uncompetitive — the holistic review compensates for the missing test data, it does not ignore the rest of the application.

The Decision Framework: Submit or Not

Work through these questions before deciding whether to submit scores to any test-optional school:

Question 1: Is your score above the 75th percentile for the school's admitted class? If yes, submit. This is essentially always the right call.

Question 2: Is your score between the 25th and 75th percentile? If yes, consider submitting, especially if the rest of your application is strong. A below-average score in the middle range is not automatically disqualifying.

Question 3: Is your score below the 25th percentile? Withholding is generally correct here. Submitting a score that is clearly weak by the school's own metrics tends to hurt more than help.

Question 4: Even if you are in the withheld zone, are you applying to a school where test scores are particularly important to their evaluation culture? Research each school's specific test-optional history — some schools that technically allow score omission have demonstrated through their outcomes data that they still lean heavily on scores when submitted.

International Applicants and Test Scores

For international applicants, the test-optional question has additional complexity. Many highly selective US universities still expect international applicants to submit test scores even when domestic applicants are given the option to withhold. The underlying logic is that grades and academic records from international systems are harder to contextualize without a standardized benchmark.

If you are an international applicant, do not assume that a domestic school's test-optional policy applies to you equally. Check specifically whether the policy applies to international applicants. In many cases, the practical expectation for competitive international applicants remains that strong SAT or ACT scores are part of a strong application.

What Happens After 2027

The test-optional question is not settled. At least several additional schools are expected to announce testing requirement returns over the next one to two cycles. The general direction at elite institutions appears to be toward reinstating requirements, driven by data showing that test scores remain one of the more reliable predictors of freshman academic performance when combined with other factors.

For students starting their junior year in fall 2026 and planning to apply in the 2027–2028 cycle, the advice is clear: take the SAT or ACT seriously. The schools that matter most to you may be test-required by the time you apply.